← InsightsIGCP | CAPITAL PARTNERS
    Valuation

    The Asset-Based Valuation: When Substance Value Counts

    IGCP Capital Partners · Published · Updated

    Cover image for article: The Asset-Based Valuation: When Substance Value Counts

    Substance value counts what is there — not what the company earns. How the asset-based method works and in which cases it actually tips the scales.

    The asset-based valuation method values a company through its assets: What would it cost to rebuild the business today with all machines, inventory and rights — minus debt? It answers a different question than income or multiple methods, which look at future earnings. That is exactly why, for most going concerns, substance value is not the price but the floor.

    Where a figure has to hold up in front of a buyer, a bank or a court, our approach to company valuation explains how we arrive at it.

    How is substance value calculated?

    All assets are valued individually at current values — machines, vehicles, inventory, property, intangible rights — and reduced by liabilities. Depending on purpose, there are two readings: reproduction value (what does rebuilding the business cost?) and liquidation value (what remains when all parts are sold individually, minus wind-down costs?).

    Liquidation value is almost always significantly lower: in a break-up, break-up prices count, not going-concern values. It is the relevant figure when continuation is no longer on the table — see below.

    When is the asset-based method relevant?

    In four situations: for asset-heavy businesses with weak earnings (substance is worth more than the earnings justify), when assessing a closure (liquidation value as benchmark), as a tax floor — in Germany, valuation may not fall below substance value under Sec. 11 (2) BewG — and as a plausibility anchor alongside other methods.

    Whether continuation, sale or closure is more economical depends on comparing going-concern and liquidation value: Closure or Sale?

    Facing this situation yourself? IGCP advises owners independently — the initial conversation is free of charge, without obligation and strictly confidential.

    Request a free initial consultation →

    Why is substance value rarely the price in a sale?

    Because buyers do not buy machines but future earnings. A company that earns sustainably is worth more than the sum of its parts — the surplus over substance is exactly what customer base, processes, team and market position represent. That is why earnings-oriented methods lead in a sale: Income Approach and DCF and the Multiplier Method as the market reality check.

    The warning applies in reverse: if the calculated income value sits below substance value, the question arises whether the business model still earns its tied-up substance — a finding buyers price in mercilessly.

    How do the three methods fit together?

    MethodPerspectiveTypical role
    Substance valueAssets todayFloor, tax minimum, liquidation comparison
    Income / DCFFuture earningsTheoretical core of valuation
    MultiplesMarket comparisonReality check: what do buyers currently pay?

    In practice all three logics count — and in the end none of them decides: the price is set by a buyer willing to pay. An overview of methods and occasions: Company Valuation.

    What does the German Valuation Act say about substance value?

    The Bewertungsgesetz (BewG, the German Valuation Act) makes substance value a floor, but only for tax valuation and with its own yardstick. Under Sec. 11 (2) BewG, shares in corporations are valued at their market value (gemeiner Wert). If this cannot be derived from sales between unrelated parties less than a year old, it is determined with regard to earnings prospects or another recognised method, namely the method a buyer would use to set the price. The sum of the market values of the assets and other asset items minus liabilities, which the statute calls substance value, may not be undercut (statutory text retrieved from gesetze-im-internet.de on 9 October 2026).

    Three points are missing from many shortened accounts:

    • Yardstick: Under Sec. 9 (2) BewG, market value is the price obtainable in the ordinary course of business on a sale. That is a sale price per asset, not necessarily the rebuild value that business-administration theory calls reproduction value.
    • Scope: The rule is not limited to GmbH shares. Sec. 109 (1) and (2) BewG applies Sec. 11 (2) correspondingly to the business assets of commercial enterprises and to interests in the business assets of partnerships.
    • Simplified method: Under Sec. 199 BewG, the simplified capitalised earnings method may be used if it does not produce obviously incorrect results. It multiplies the sustainably achievable annual earnings by the capitalisation factor, which is 13.75 under Sec. 203 (1) BewG. Non-operating assets are added separately at their own market value under Sec. 200 (2) BewG.

    Worked example with freely chosen figures, for illustration only and without market reference: A business with sustainable annual earnings of EUR 120,000 reaches 120,000 × 13.75 = EUR 1,650,000 under the simplified method. If the sum of the market values of its assets minus liabilities is EUR 1,900,000, the tax value may not fall below EUR 1.9 million. A buyer, by contrast, would anchor the price on earnings, risk and transferability. The two figures answer different questions and should not be confused.

    This matters for family succession because gift and inheritance tax draw on these values. How to plan succession and valuation together is described in business succession in Germany.

    When does liquidation value act as a floor?

    In valuation standards, liquidation value is treated as the floor of company value, but not automatically.

    In Austria, the expert opinion KFS/BW 1 states that liquidation value is in principle the floor, unless legal or factual constraints prevent liquidation (para. 13). It is the present value of the proceeds from selling the assets minus repayment of debt, taking liquidation costs and tax effects into account (para. 133). It is determined not in every valuation but where there are indications that going-concern value could be lower, for example where it falls below book equity. Faster wind-down usually yields lower proceeds. Source: ICON Wirtschaftstreuhand's account of the recommendation of 16 January 2019, article of 6 February 2019, retrieved on 9 October 2026; the original text of the expert opinion governs.

    In Germany, the literature points to IDW S 1 (2008 version): liquidation value comes into play when its present value exceeds the capitalised earnings value; where there is a legal or factual compulsion to continue, going-concern value remains decisive. According to the law firm Kleeberg's account of 4 December 2025 (retrieved on 9 October 2026), case law too knows no automatism; we have not checked the decisions cited there against the originals and therefore do not cite them.

    QuestionTax substance value (BewG)Liquidation value (valuation standards)
    PurposeMinimum value in tax valuationFloor when continuation does not carry
    YardstickMarket values of assets minus liabilitiesPresent value of realisation proceeds minus debt and wind-down costs
    ApplicationPrescribed by statuteOnly where going-concern value may fall below realisation value

    What follows for sellers?

    If earnings value sits below substance value, a three-step review is worthwhile:

    1. Operating or not? Property, financial assets or idle plant that the business does not need are, in practice, valued separately alongside earnings value. For tax valuation, Sec. 200 (2) BewG provides exactly that. Separating them before the sale can lower the price for the core business and raise the total proceeds.
    2. Does the substance earn its cost? Assets that permanently work below the cost of capital are a risk for buyers, not a value. A discount is then more realistic than book values.
    3. Is continuation really intended? An owner who would close the business anyway compares sale price and liquidation value. That comparison belongs before the first buyer conversation, not after.

    How a sale process runs from valuation through buyer outreach to negotiation is set out under selling a company.

    FAQ

    For which companies is substance value the right valuation?

    For businesses whose value actually lies in assets: property companies, asset-heavy operations without sustainable earnings, wind-down cases. For profitable service, trading or technology companies it systematically underestimates value.

    What is the difference between substance value and liquidation value?

    Substance value assumes continuation and asks for replacement values; liquidation value assumes break-up and asks for individual sale proceeds minus wind-down costs. The gap can be large. How large depends on how saleable the plant is, how long the wind-down takes and what it costs; there is no flat ratio.

    Does substance value play a role in inheritance and gift tax?

    Yes: in Germany it forms the floor of tax valuation under Sec. 11 (2) BewG, applied correspondingly to business assets via Sec. 109 BewG. What that means in the individual case belongs to your tax advisor — classifying the methods does not change the fact that tax valuation is its own field.

    The real value emerges in negotiation, not in the formula. For a realistic, independent assessment: IGCP Capital Partners. → igcp.at

    Whether the earnings value of your company sits well above its net asset value is visible from a rough calculation: calculate your company value.

    SubstanzwertverfahrenSubstanzwertUnternehmensbewertungLiquidationswertBewertungsverfahren

    Related services

    More insights